Friday, April 25, 2008
Guess who will introduce Bob Olson on Saturday?
Former Minnesota Attorney General and US District Court Judge Miles Lord will introduce Olson at the CD 6 Convention.
Two thoughts...
It may make Olson look bad since Judge Lord did come out pretty hard after Tinklenberg's taconite dealings earlier this week.
However, Judge Lord is a powerful figure for working and middle class Minnesotans. He served 5 years as Minnesota Attorney General and was succeeded by Walter Mondale. He was appointed by President Johnson and served nearly 20 years as a US District Court Judge, where he is most famous for going after mining companies dumping taconite tailings in Lake Superior. He is also well known for going after A.H. Robins Company for malpractice in issuing the Dalkon Shield intrauterine device.
At 88 years old, Judge Lord is still fighting for the "little guy". His speech tomorrow will be interesting. I hear the Tinklenberg Campaign is not pleased about this development.
Stay tuned for the live blog tomorrow.
Wednesday, April 23, 2008
Taconite follows Tinklenberg again
Former federal judge Miles Lord, who 30 years ago famously stopped Reserve Mining Co. from dumping tons of carcinogenic tailings in Lake Superior, distributed a letter at the luncheon and made statements essentially accusing Tinklenberg of helping spread "deadly taconite tailings" in Minnesota and across the country.
Tinklenberg defended the work, saying that the Natural Resources Research Institute (NRRI) at the University of Minnesota Duluth had tested the rock and found it safe, and that his role has been limited.
"It is not our project," he said. "We've only been asked to explore markets."
Right, he's contracted to market Taconite tailings. The appropriate question would be who payed for the study saying this stuff was safe? If the mining industry or other groups who would profit off the use of taconite tailings paid for the study, it ought to be vigorously questioned.
Tinklenberg, who hopes to win the DFL's endorsement Saturday in Coon Rapids to face Republican incumbent Michele Bachmann, is a former mayor of Blaine and served as Transportation Department commissioner under Gov. Jesse Ventura. After leaving MnDOT, Tinklenberg created a firm specializing in transportation and land-use issues.
No mention of Bob Olson in the story.
Janet O'Connell of Lake Elmo, who also asked questions of Tinklenberg at the luncheon, said that more research must be done on the possible ties between taconite and cancer. She developed an interest in the issue after it came out last year that 35 Iron Range miners died of mesothelioma between 1997 and 2005.
"My concern is, if they use [taconite tailings], what's going to happen to my children and your children," she said.
BTW, Erik Paulsen voted against a U of M study on the cancer epidemic that has swept through Iron Range taconite miners.
Monday, March 24, 2008
Taconite Good, Road Salt Bad?
One headline caught my eye.
"The Trouble With Road Salt".
I showed Bluewoman the headline and posed the question, "what do you think I'll write about?"
She knew instantly...
If road salt is so bad for the environment, what about the controversial use of taconite tailings? Remember, the mining industry can no longer dump them in Lake Superior but we can use them on roads.
The effort to reduce road-salt use is driven largely by the legal requirement to protect aquatic life. However, as is often the case with environmental regulation, reduced road-salt pollution would have other benefits. A well-tuned adaptive management strategy could actually improve winter-driving conditions using less road salt (a shift from a brawn strategy to a brains strategy). Using less road salt would reduce corrosion of vehicles and bridge decks. According to a study by the Federal Highway Administration, bridge-deck corrosion costs $8.3 billion per year in direct costs (and 10 times more in indirect costs), much of it caused by salt. The same study reported that $23.4 billion is spent annually to avoid or repair corrosion to vehicles. The effort to reduce road-salt use would probably yield economic benefits that far exceed costs.
Some would argue the same with taconite tailings.
Sunday, March 16, 2008
Tinklenberg's Taconite: Rumor or not?
Denials of Tinklenberg's federal lobby work and endorsements were filled with rhetoric.
Tinklenberg also fully denies any negative impact from taconite tailings.
The second issue had to do with taconite tailings, a by-product of iron mining, and speculation that I was involved in a project that was potentially exposing people to asbestos and the resulting cancer risk.
This is a horrible accusation and particularly so because my first wife died of cancer and I would never be involved in anything that would expose others to the misery my family went through. This is a rumor that was invented two years ago by a staffer for the Wetterling campaign and I believed it had been refuted effectively at that time. I am saddened to see it resurfacing in an attempt to damage my character.
The project I have worked on is sponsored by the University of Minnesota's Natural
Resources Research Institute (NRRI) and is funded by a grant from the U.S. Economic Development Agency. The goal of the project is to conduct additional testing of by-products of taconite mining in the western portion of the iron range for suitability as transportation aggregate. The work is being led by the University.
A secondary goal is to identify potential markets for the use of this material as a transportation aggregate, should the testing support it. That's the work in which I have been involved. The use of these western range materials in this way has consistently been approved by MnDOT, NRRI, the PCA and the EPA. Additional testing and monitoring is ongoing and should any concerns surface, I'm certain the University would suspend the project; an action I would support. For additional information you can contact Larry Zenko at the National Resources Research Institute.Source: Tinklenberg Campaign email, 3/10/08.
Upon further review, it's actually Larry Zanko. I'm sure it was just a typo, the Tinklenberg Campaign would not intentionally deceive any of us.
What we've found is rather interesting.
Building on previous taconite aggregate research efforts, the NRRI’s Economic Geology Group is leading a comprehensive research and demonstration program that is designed to accelerate the usage of Minnesota’s vast quantities of taconite mining byproducts for construction aggregate purposes. The three-year (2006-2008) program is being supported with $1,250,000 of federal funding from the Department of Commerce, Economic Development Administration, and an additional $416,667 of matching funds from the Permanent University Trust Fund, Iron Range Resources, Minnesota Power, the Blandin Foundation, and Minnesota Technology, Inc.
Source: Natural Resources Research Institute
How much of the $1.25 million was Tinklenberg given to market or lobby for taconite tailings?
"This is very important, not just in terms of the economy of the Range here in Minnesota, but the quality of our transportation system throughout the country. We are confident that the quality of the aggregate available in Minnesota’s iron mining area will prove to be a valuable resource for transportation,"said El Tinklenberg, President of the Tinklenberg Group, who has worked with NRRI in developing markets for this aggregate material. "The use of this recycled material also has important environmental benefits."
Source: Congressman Jim Oberstar Press Release, 10/7/2004.
Important environmental benefits? The City Pages had an interesting story called "The microwavable road? A Brave New Highway.
Retired federal judge Miles Lord and former Minnesota Pollution Control Agency chief Grant Merritt seem to have some concerns.
At the Center for Transportation Studies seminar, two old lions of Minnesota's environmental movement--retired federal judge Miles Lord and former Minnesota Pollution Control Agency chief Grant Merritt--raised objections based on the possible health risks. Both Lord and Merritt are concerned because some taconite tailings are known to contain asbestos and asbestos-like fibers. Those fibers, they fear, may be related to the elevated levels of a rare but deadly cancer called mesothelioma on the Iron Range.
From 1988 to 1999, according to a 2003 Minnesota Department of Health study, there were 81 identified cases of mesothelioma among residents of northeastern Minnesota, nearly double the expected rate. For that reason alone, Merritt contends, any use of taconite tailings in highways should be subjected to a full environmental review.
Lord, who issued the landmark 1974 ruling that prohibited the dumping of taconite tailings into Lake Superior, takes a more conspiratorial view. The use of taconite tailings on highways, Lord contends, represents "a deliberate attempt by the taconite industry and its owners, 'Big Steel,' to spread deadly particles on Minnesota highways, thereby making it difficult, if not impossible, to pinpoint the cause of cancer deaths on the Iron Range because cancer will occur throughout the state of Minnesota."
Source: City Pages, November 30, 2005.
We can't dump this stuff in Lake Superior but we can use it all over our roads?
Doesn't this conflict with Tinklenberg's statement that "this recycled material also has important environmental benefits"?
Not all within the EPA believe that taconite tailings are 100% safe.
Chrysotile asbestos is the main type of asbestos used in the U.S. Some say it is not a carcinogen. Cook believes that it is a carcinogen. Amphibole crystals are present in taconite (iron ore) from Northeast Minnesota – ferroactinolite replaces hornblende in some rocks with cummingtonitegrunerite being the most common amphibole overall. Ferroactinolite appears to be the amphibole which is most consistently fibrous. Amphibole can’t be extracted from the rock for use, but it has fiber-like characteristics and can be released in dust when the rock is crushed. Particles of chrysotile or amphibole asbestos occur as thin fibers or in bundles that can enter the lungs and cause asbestosis. However, short fibers that can break off of larger rodlike bundles can be respirable, as well. In the past, scientists have tended not to consider the risk from the short fibers, and science today still rests on dose-response relationships based on light microscopy, which was inadequate for detecting short and thin fibers. The assumption was that only the longer and thicker fibers pose a health risk.
Source: EPA Workshop on Emerging Pollutants, August 11-13, 2003, Page 54.
Conflicting views from both the Pollution Control Agency and the EPA.
Minnesota State Senator John Marty has concerns over taconite tailings and the Minnesota Department of Health cover-up.
Why was this failure to release the information about additional miner deaths so harmful? Back in 2003, the Health Department learned that 17 taconite miners had died from mesothelioma, an asbestos-related form of cancer. At that time the department suggested that it was not taconite dust, but the use of commercial asbestos in certain mining operations that caused the cancer. In March of 2006, when the department learned that an additional 35 miners had died from mesothelioma, it appeared more likely that the cause was asbestos-like fibers in taconite dust. This means the risk was not only for workers doing welding or other jobs where asbestos was once used, but virtually every mine worker might be susceptible to this deadly cancer.
-"Some scientists have publicly criticized the findings of (the Health Department's) 2003 study, in which you pinned the mesothelioma cases on commercial asbestos rather than taconite dust....Don't the additional mesothelioma cases call those findings into question?"
Source: To The Point, July 9, 2007. Sen John Marty.
Questions about taconite tailings and cancer are abundant. A definitive study calling taconite tailings 100% safe is missing. A definitive study calling taconite tailings 100% harmful is missing as well. However, enough evidence has been shown that a serious, non-mining industry, public study is warranted.
Recently, Congersswoman Betty McCollum introduced the "Bruce Vento Ban Asbestos and Prevent Meslothelioma Act of 2008".
“It’s long past time that our country banned asbestos,” McCollum said. “After decades of widespread and unknowing exposure to this deadly substance, Americans should be able to rest assured that they are no longer at risk of having their lives cut short by asbestos exposure.”
We couldn't agree more.
Rumor or not? You be the judge.
Monday, March 10, 2008
Tinklenberg denies lobbying: DC Watchdog Groups disagree
On Saturday the 8th, we had our first round of large senate district conventions. In the course of meeting with delegates, I and my staff were met with some questions that both surprised and disturbed us. I feel that it's important to clear up the speculation that has apparently been running wild on blogs (me, Liberal in the Land of Conservative, Developers are Crabgrass and MnBlue) and through the DFL activists via the Olson campaign and its supporters. (Bloggers added)
They knew about this stuff much earlier! February 4th 2008, Larry Schumacher at the SC Times posted a story about Tinklenberg's denial on his blog.
It quoted John Wodele, Spokesman for Tinklenberg 2008. They knew about this a long time ago, starting after the 12/13/07 SD 19 meeting.
Tinklenberg spokesman John Wodele got back to me Monday and said he considers the accusation to be not a legitimate news story, since he said the US Attorney's office has rejected the letter's request.
Wodele lied. The letter was actually forwarded to the proper authorities.
Recall what the DC Watchdog groups think?
Craig Holman, PhD. Public Citizen
The evidence presented here strongly suggests that Tinklenberg has met the threshold of a federal lobbyist:
(1) Receives compensation of $5,000 or more per six months
(2) makes expenditures of $20,000 or more per six months
(3) Spends at least 20% of his time on behalf of any single client conducting lobbying activity.
(4) Made more than one lobbying contact with a "covered official" (member of Congress).
Since there is some evidence that the threshold has been met, it is appropriate to file a complaint with the Secretary of the Senate and the Clerk of the House, requesting that they investigate the matter. You may also want to copy directly to Tinklenberg for faster action. You will probably see him scramble to register and disclose.
Glad you guys are on this.
We just caught ADM (also in Minnesota) not registering, and ADM is now in compliance with the law.
Greg Gasiewski: Lobbying Researcher for the Center for Responsive Politics
The Lobbying Disclosure Act of 1995's definition of a lobbyist:
LOBBYIST.—The term ”lobbyist” means any individual who is employed or retained by a client for financial or other compensation for services that include more than one lobbying contact, other than an individual whose lobbying activities constitute less than 20 percent of the time engaged in the services provided by such individual to that client over a 3-month period.
Certainly sounds like it to me.
We'll continue to give the Tinklenberg email a good fisking.
Thursday, March 06, 2008
Around the blogs
Liberal in the Land of Conservative has a post up (with You Tubes), on the Paul Wellstone Mental Health and Addiction Equity Act of 2007, opposed by Bachmann and Kline. Rumor has it that Rep Kline tried to strip Paul Wellstone's name from the bill.
Ollie at Bluestem Prairie has posts up about Tim Walz's response to the Paul Wellstone Mental Health Act and a new Tim Walz ad released by American's United for Change.
I Don't Hate America posts on DM&E and the railroad safety plan.
Spotty endorses Jack Nelson Pallmeyer for US Senate.
MDE is going crazy of Al Franken's Worker's Comp scandal.
Larry Schumacher, St Cloud Times, has an anniversary today. 1 year of Democracy at Work! Congrats Larry!
Minnesota Campaign Report Endorses Ashwin Madia in CD 3!
Tuesday, March 04, 2008
Question of the day: Taconite related (Updated)
We regret the mistake. McCollum has no connections to the story. Although I do remain concerned about the DCCC's concerns over Tinklenberg's taconite.
Saturday, February 23, 2008
Eric Z ponders Tinklenberg's Taconite
My expectation would be that differences would be minor but telling. I expect Olson would have a more detached view, apart from jobs-for-the-Iron-Range being a myopic and governing concern. However, his advocacy of energy independence and energy alternatives - such as wind energy's potential for weaning foreign oil dependence and for creating manufacturing job potentials in Minnesota, is an advocacy that has to realize that copper and nickel are important for plant and equipment bearings, stainless and other specialty steels, and for equiping wind turbine generation sites and for arranging transmission grid access and management expansions. Any wind turbine, even a single small scale site, would involve clutching and control, generator internals where nickel might be a permanent magnet alloy component, and copper is the element of choice for coil windings. Without mining, recycling alone would be relied upon, and with an expanding world and competing nations, growth of the metals in use and available would be necessary. From that practical perspective, Olson would more likely be in favor of a studied and cautious approach - with minimized long term environmental downside, whereas Tinklenberg would want more jobs in Oberstar's district yesterday with myopia toward downside risks.
Indeed, Olson is solid on sustainable / renewable energy sources, in an effort to both, protect the environment and to end our reliance on foreign oil.
With the amount of traffic I am seeing with Tinklenberg Taconite, I think something deeper may be coming on this isssue soon!
Monday, February 18, 2008
Tinklenberg and taconite
What's going on with that?